The lie, the bluff and false confessions, describes a series of laboratory experiments that test how the bluff technique correlates with confessions gained from innocent parties. Regardless of the age, capacity, or state of the confessor, what they often have in common is a decisionat some point during the interrogation processthat confessing will be more beneficial to them than. Jim trainum, a retired washington, dc, homicide detective, explores the nature of this problem in his book, how the police generate false confessions, and discusses how the interview process can be improved and reformed. After a description of the three sequential processes that are responsible for the. This is a list of wrongful convictions in the united states.
False confessions take place everywhere in this country. Legal issue policeinduced false confessions are among the leading causes of wrongful convictions. Did a false confession lead to ryan fergusons wrongful. In true stories of false confessions, warden and drizin have collected 39 actual cases, written by authors like john grisham and alex kotlowitz, in which people said they were responsible for crimes they did not commit. Second, few convictions based on false confessions are cleared by exoneration. False confession risk increases for susceptible suspects e. Until these methodological obstacles are overcome, no one can authoritatively estimate the rate of policeinduced false confessions or the annual number of wrongful convictions caused by false confessions. False confession cases always result from the way that an interrogation has taken place. Forensic dna evidence has been a gamechanger for law enforcement, but research shows it can contribute to miscarriages of justice.
False confessions false confessions may be one of the most confusing of all the primary contributors to wrongful convictions because it involves selfindictment. Research studies have pinpointed the reasons why false confessions happen and what reforms are needed. Why 9 innocent people went to jail ledura watkins, 61, was cleared of murder last year, more than 41 years after he was convicted. False confessions in many cases, innocent defendants make incriminating statements, deliver outright confessions, or plead guilty. False confessions are a contributing factor in almost 30% of dna exonerations in the united states. Wrongful convictions resulting from false confessions. How often do false confessions lead to miscarriages of justice. A confession is seen to be very powerful evidence of guilt, which is why false confessions can easily lead to wrongful convictions. He has pioneered the scientific study of false confessions and his research has been integral in preventing wrongful convictions and understanding why innocent people are targeted for interrogation, why they confess and the effect of this evidence on judges and juries. In the past two decades, hundreds of convicted prisoners have been exonerated by dna and nondna evidence, revealing that policeinduced false confessions are a leading cause of wrongful conviction of the innocent. Policeinduced false confessions are among the leading causes of wrongful convictions. To combat false confessions and wrongful convictions, innocent defendants must turn to social scientists and expert witnesses to present evidence on the dynamics of false confessions.
False confessions and how they happen the washington post. Lengthy interrogations or exhaustion can also cause people to falsely confess. List of wrongful convictions in the united states wikipedia. Prosecutors can fail to turn over evidence, or defense attorneys dont provide effective counsel. For decades, we have seen false confession after false confession lead to tragic wrongful convictions of the. Working to free the wrongfully convicted and to prevent wrongful convictions in minnesota, north dakota, and south dakota. The book concludes with policy recommendations to attenuate the. Mar 14, 2018 false confessions, mistaken witnesses, corrupt investigators. Specific topics include eyewitness identification, false confessions, prosecutors and police. The psychology of false confessions the impious digest. The eighteenyear fight to save four innocent men,by david protess and rob warden 1998 actual innocence.
After a description of the three sequential processes that are responsible for. The death penalty information center has examined our exoneration database and crossreferenced it with the national registry of exonerations information on deathrow exonerations in the last decade between 2007 and april 2017 to determine the most common factors that contributed to the wrongful convictions and death sentences for the most. Preventing false confessions from becoming wrongful convictions. It can be difficult to understand why a person would wrongly confess to a crime they did not commit. When law enforcement officials are under great pressure to solve a case, finding the right perpetrator can become a secondary priority and if necessary, they will use coercion and intimidation to obtain a. So even after men like douglas warney are finally freed after years of wrongful imprisonment. In addition to a variety of factors, instances of false confession have been identified as a contributing cause of some wrongful convictions. May 18, 2009 torture and false confessions much of the media storm around torture these days focuses on the moral compromise the u.
False confessions, mistaken witnesses, corrupt investigators. Recording interrogations prevents false confessions from leading to wrongful convictions. According to the national registry of exonerations, of 1,900 wrongful convictions in their data base, 234 were caused by false confessions, or about 12 percent. All stories linked in the newsletter are free to access. After getting a cursory look at wrongful convictions via personal accounts.
False confessions innocent defendants have made incriminating statements, confessed, or plead guilty in approximately 25 percent of dna exonerations in the united states. Since the dna exonerations by the innocence project have conclusively proven the innocence of some confessed offenders, social scientists have been able to examine false confessions in more detail. False confessions university of michigan law school. Specific topics include eyewitness identification, false confessions, prosecutors and police, preservation of evidence, defense counsel, scientific and forensic evidence, informants, adjudication, capital cases, and. Leo, phd, jd in the past two decades, hundreds of convicted prisoners have been exonerated by dna and nondna evidence, revealing that policeinduced false confessions are a leading cause of wrongful conviction of the innocent. There is no single cause of false confession, and there is no single logic or type of false confession. People are unwilling to believe that someone who has confessed to a crime did not actually commit that crime. Brendan dasseys lawyer recommends these 17 books on false.
Wrightsman and kassin 1993 report that no one knows but cited lloyd bostocks report 1989 that in great britain, false confessions ranked second only to mistaken identifications as a cause of wrongful conviction among. The entire interrogation during the time in which a reasonable person in the subjects position would consider himself to be in custody and a law enforcement officers questioning is likely to elicit incriminating responses should be electronically recorded. Mistaken eyewitness identification and false confessions can lead to wrongful convictions. Wrongful convictions following shocking false confessions. Causes of wrongful convictions new england innocence project. This list includes people who have been legally exonerated, including people whose convictions have been overturned or vacated, and who have not been retried because the charges were dismissed by the states. The story of a murder, a false confession, and the struggle to free a. Jan 15, 2015 false memories for committing crime also shared many characteristics with true memories. Wrongful convictions is a pet issue of mine, especially when theyre achieved. Causes of wrongful conviction washington innocence project. Editors rob warden and steven drizinleaders in the field of wrongful convictionshave gathered articles about some of the most critical accounts of false confessions in the u. Coerced confession law how to avoid wrongful conviction.
In many cases, racism and implicit bias play a significant role in the wrongful conviction of innocent people of color. The criminology of wrongful conviction sage journals. However, as a new book edited by rob warden and steve drizin of the center on wrongful convictions shows, a confession is sometimes only the beginning of the real story. When law enforcement officials are under great pressure to solve a case, finding the right perpetrator can become a secondary priority and if necessary, they will use coercion and intimidation to obtain a confession from a suspect. Dec 06, 2017 forensic dna evidence has been a gamechanger for law enforcement, but research shows it can contribute to miscarriages of justice. There are two main types of police interrogation techniques that are considered coercive. Thats true for all wrongful convictions, but especially for those based on confessions.
In fact, one quarter of those defendants exonerated by dna evidence had confessed to the crime they clearly didnt commit. Compiled by amelia hritz, michal blau, and sara tomezsko. The university of connecticut psychology department invites uconn law students to attend a psychology colloquium addressing the questions of why innocent people confess to crimes they did not commit, why judges and juries unflinchingly believe these false confessions, and how the system can be reformed to prevent the wrongful convictions that result. Wrongful convictions resulting from false confessions lawinfo. Schanberg, christine ellen young, alex kotlowitz, and john grisham. Books and movies about wrongful conviction innocence. Finding ways to reduce wrongful convictions houston.
It deters against coercive or illegal interrogation practices and alerts investigators, judges and jurors if suspects have mental illness, intellectual disabilities or other vulnerabilities that make them more susceptible to false. False confessions, given separately, led to the wrongful murder convictions of the norfolk four. Therefore, false confessions certainly can lead to wrongful convictions. The first is the miranda warnings designed to establish procedural safeguards to protect a suspect from unknowingly. False memories for committing crime also shared many characteristics with true memories.
Below are guides from the innocence project explaining various factors that lead to wrongful. Police interrogation is only the first step in a false confessionbased wrongful conviction. The first is the miranda warnings designed to establish procedural safeguards to protect a suspect from unknowingly incriminating himself. The rate of wrongful convictions in people with an asd is not known, but may be higher than the rate for in neurotypicals given these difficulties. Multiple factors can contribute to false confessions, such as a defendants poor mental health andor the. The wrongful convictions of john kogut, dennis halstead, and john restivo. Finding ways to reduce wrongful convictions houston chronicle. False testimonyconfessions false confession cases cip.
People with disabilities are likely to give a false confession, because they are tempted to accommodate and respect authority. Changes need to be made that do away with false confessions. Innocent persons, however, have been known to falsely confess to crimes they did not commit. Homicide detectives book describes how the police generate. The fact is that false confessions are one of the leading causes of wrongful convictions. The psychology of interrogations and false confessions. Jan 30, 2016 false confessions take place everywhere in this country. They cover correlates, causes, consequences, and the incidence of wrongful convictions, and offer recommendations for reform. Oct 20, 2016 according to the national registry of exonerations, of 1,900 wrongful convictions in their data base, 234 were caused by false confessions, or about 12 percent. Jun 12, 2016 thats true for all wrongful convictions, but especially for those based on confessions.
When justice goes wrong and how to make it right, by barry scheck, peter neufeld and jim dwyer 2000. How forensic dna evidence can lead to wrongful convictions. So even after men like douglas warney are finally freed after years of. If unchallenged, however, coerced confessions can lead to misdemeanor or felony charges. Its very hard to convince people that a defendant who confessed is innocent. If the underlying basis for the false confession is fear, coercion, impairment, or ignorance, however, then there may be grounds to overturn a wrongful conviction on appeal. When the three men first imprisoned for her murder were found to have been wrongfully convicted, it seemed that her killer would go unpunished. Sep 05, 2010 some 85 percent of wrongful convictions in texas are due to mistaken eyewitness identifications the no. About 25% of wrongful convictions overturned by dna testing have involved a false confession or admission. Some 85 percent of wrongful convictions in texas are due to mistaken eyewitness identifications the no.
Leo, phd, jd in the past two decades, hundreds of convicted prisoners have been exonerated by dna and nondna evidence, revealing that policeinduced false confessions are a leading cause of. He is a leading authority on police interrogations and coerced confessions. Exonerations of defendants who confessed are more likely to depend on the most unassailable evidencednato overcome the weight of a confession. Recording is the most commonly recommended safeguard against wrongful convictions stemming from false confessions. Multiple factors can contribute to false confessions, such as a defendants poor mental health andor the use of coercive interrogation techniques. One of the biggest causes of wrongful convictions is the false assumption that no one would ever confess to a crime they didnt commit. Researchers who study this phenomenon have determined that the following factors contribute to or cause false confessions. Criminal law acknowledges three main types of false confessions. People with an intellectual disability, perhaps especially those with adhd, are also more likely than other police interviewees to make false confessions, which may lead to wrongful imprisonment. The eighteenyear fight to save four innocent men,by david protess and rob warden 1998.
Many of the nations more than 360 wrongful convictions overturned by dna evidence involved some form of a false confession. Regardless of the age, capacity, or state of the confessor, what they often have in common is a decisionat some point during the interrogation processthat confessing will be. Why 9 innocent people went to jail ledura watkins, 61, was cleared of murder last year, more than 41. If onequarter of information gleaned from torture was false leading to wrongful arrests and convictions and to costly goose chases. Study suggests causes of and ways to prevent false confessions. False confessions are a leading cause of wrongful convictions. A 2011 study published in law and human behavior, inside interrogation. Exonerations of defendants who confessed are more likely to depend on the most unassailable evidence, dna, to overcome the weight of a confession. Homicide detectives book describes how the police generate false confessions. Mar 31, 2020 recording is the most commonly recommended safeguard against wrongful convictions stemming from false confessions.
1314 1189 543 989 888 861 583 661 142 461 243 20 1080 359 435 1397 1462 813 409 214 939 536 1096 168 700 146 1107 404 1230 838 324 319 821 492